Project Hail Mary: Journey Among The Stars Review

Meta Quest 3
• written by
Cover image for Project Hail Mary: Journey Among The Stars Review - Meta Quest 3

Rocky is wonderful, but frustrating hand tracking keeps this mixed reality journey from reaching the stars

I absolutely adored the Project Hail Mary movie. I think it is one of the best sci-fi movies ever made, and the friendship between Ryan Gosling's Grace and Rocky got me good. Tears were shed, okay? So the idea of spending more time with those two on the Hail Mary was an easy sell. Unfortunately, actually playing Project Hail Mary: Journey Among The Stars left me pretty disappointed.

The screenshots in this review are from the Meta Quest store, and the game running on Quest 3 does not look anywhere near this good. I did not capture my own screenshots because doing that while using hand tracking on Quest kinda sucks. Check out the video for a better look at how the game actually looks in action.

This is a mixed reality adventure from Maze Theory, a studio that knows its way around an immersive game. I loved Infinite Inside, which combined mixed reality puzzles with wonderfully atmospheric VR exploration, and I also enjoyed the studio's Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow. That made me excited to see what it could do with a world and characters I already cared about. The result has some lovely moments, mostly thanks to Rocky, but getting to them involves far too much wrestling with the controls.

A virtual hand reaches toward a control in the Hail Mary

The game puts you in Grace's shoes during a previously unseen part of his journey with Rocky. The two are trying to keep the Hail Mary functioning and protect their precious cargo on the way to Rocky's home. It is a neat space for a new story, and I like the idea of seeing more of their friendship while they work through another series of problems together. If you loved the movie, just hearing Rocky again is enough to put a smile on your face.

And Rocky really is the best thing here. His familiar voice, performed by James Ortiz from the movie, and his expressive movements bring back so much of what made him such a memorable character. Give him a thumbs up and watch his response, do jazz hands, or play rock, paper, scissors with him. These little exchanges are delightful. For a moment, I could forget the frustrations and just enjoy hanging out with my favorite alien engineer.

Rocky responds to a thumbs up aboard the Hail Mary

The problem is that everything around those moments kept pulling me right back out. Journey Among The Stars is mixed reality only on Quest 3. Instead of stepping into a fully realized spaceship, you see virtual objects and detailed 3D models appear in your actual room through passthrough. Some of those models look cool, but seeing my own surroundings behind them never made me feel like I was aboard the Hail Mary.

Mixed reality can be great when the experience is built around your space in a way that feels natural. Here, though, a roughly two-by-two-meter roomscale area is needed, and I couldn't find a way to reposition things once they appeared. That is frustrating when an object ends up somewhere awkward in your room. A little more control over placement would make a big difference, especially when everyone's furniture and available space are different.

A hand operates a ship mechanism

I kept wishing there was a full VR mode. Let me leave my living room behind, walk around the ship, and interact with its systems using Touch controllers. Infinite Inside understood the appeal of bringing something mysterious into your room and then taking you somewhere else entirely. Here, I was always aware that the adventure was happening on top of my room, and that made the spacefaring fantasy much harder to buy into.

The bigger issue, though, is that hand tracking is the only way to play. Quest hand tracking can be excellent for navigating menus, and using your bare hands sounds like a natural fit for this kind of experience. But this game asks for more precision than I could reliably get out of it. You grab floating objects, move them into place, operate little switches, and turn dials. When those actions work, they are straightforward. When they don't, they become an exercise in trying the same small movement over and over.

I found myself struggling to pick things up, then carefully moving them toward the spot where they needed to go, hoping the game would register what I was doing. Instead of feeling like an engineer working through a problem with Rocky, I was concentrating on whether my virtual hand had actually grabbed the thing in front of me. There is no satisfying physical feedback to help, either, and I really missed the certainty of pressing a controller button.

Objects float in the Hail Mary near a raised hand

That would be easier to forgive if the tasks themselves were consistently exciting. As it stands, a lot of the moment-to-moment play feels like grabbing an object and slowly putting it somewhere else. The tracking problems turn simple jobs into tedious ones, but even when everything behaves, those interactions rarely feel particularly inventive or rewarding. It is a shame because the premise of keeping a spaceship alive alongside Rocky should be a fantastic setup for hands-on problem solving.

I also ran into a couple of bugs during my time with the game, adding another layer of frustration to an experience that already felt unresponsive too often. Between that and the finicky interactions, it was difficult to settle into the story or enjoy the sense of working together. Every time I started getting invested, another awkward grab or uncooperative interaction seemed ready to interrupt me.

There is still something special about seeing Rocky react to you, and fans who just want a little more time with him may find those moments worthwhile. I certainly did. But I wanted an adventure that made me feel like his crewmate, and too often I felt like I was fighting my headset in my living room. Journey Among The Stars has a lovely character at its heart, but its limited options and frustrating interactions make it a disappointing trip. Thanks for reading!

Final Verdict

Niche

Project Hail Mary: Journey Among The Stars

Rocky brings plenty of charm to Project Hail Mary: Journey Among The Stars, but frustrating hand tracking and limited mixed reality options make this a disappointing adventure.

Score

6

/ 10

This game was reviewed on Meta Quest 3 based on a review copy provided by PR. Project Hail Mary: Journey Among The Stars is available on Meta Quest, PICO, and Android XR.

Follow Duuro on Google

See more of our gaming coverage

Add Duuro as a preferred source to find our latest stories more often in Google Search.

Add to Preferred Sources

Articles you might like

Recommended
8.5
• written by Krist Duro

VMX Review - Meta Quest 3

VMX makes BMX, mountain biking and scooter tricks feel surprisingly natural in VR, though its wild motion can upset even experienced players.

Recommended
8.5
• written by Krist Duro

Roboquest VR Review - Meta Quest 3

Roboquest VR brings blistering movement and varied builds to Meta Quest 3. Its roguelite shooting works in VR despite a few interaction quirks.

Recommended
8
• written by Krist Duro

Compass Review - Meta Quest 3

Compass is a cozy VR flying adventure with lovely pastel skies, satisfying grappling and a simple exploration loop, even if the cockpit controls feel off.

Recommended
8.5
• written by Krist Duro

Space Control Review - Meta Quest 3

Space Control is a wild and funny adult VR adventure with a fantastic cast and chaotic story beats, even if its gameplay systems are linear and a bit janky.